Pdf military art of peoples war by vo nguyen giap perlego. The problem with this approach is that quite a few copies of that book are available in the united states, so it is fairly easy to get one, and find that giap made no such statement in it. In two editions which were most successful, we introduced a series of articles written by general vo nguyen giap on the occasion of the fourth anniver sary of the dien bien phu victory. Prelude to americas war in vietnam, he does not attempt to whitewash any of diems faults but. There is a good chance he specifically mentions kerry. Referring to the defeat of the french, giap says, peoples war, longterm war, guerilla sic warfare developing stepbystep into mobile warfare, such are the most valuable lessons of the war of liberation in vietnam. Nov 08, 2011 nam in 1961, general giap placed the strategy of a longterm war first on his list, and earlier, during the war against the french, truong chinh observed that the guiding principle of the strategy of our whole resistance must be to prolong the war. Resistance was the only way to defend the country and the fruit of the revolution.
Skirmishes were lost and missions could be called failures, but no serious groupings of us forces were really ever beaten. From the first days of the resistance, our party had pointed out. Oct 12, 20 general giap, once a history teacher, thought it would be worth preserving in the records of a free vietnam. This is the first edition, first printing of how the north vietnamese army pushed the united states out of vietnam in the mid1970s. The tet offensive of 1968 proved to be the turning point of the vietnam war and its effects were farreaching.
Some writers say he received a law degree in 1937, others. Say that the statement appeared in how we won the war, published in 1976. Apr 09, 2008 but we were elated to notice your media was definitely helping us. For most of the 1980s, giap was a political outcast, occasionally wheeled out on ceremonial occasions but stripped of all real power. How we won the war by general vo nguyen giap vietnam war book. In short, we sought a decisive victory that would persuade america to renounce the war.
The offensive that began in april is not in the protractedwarfare style projected by ho chi minh. Supposedly, general giap had written in how we won the war that in the aftermath of the tet offensive of 1968, the communist leaders in vietnam had been ready to abandon the war, but that a. Currey makes clear one primary reason why america lost the vietnam war. Books by vo nguyen giap author of peoples war peoples army. Understanding the conditions under which weak actors win wars is important for two reasons. General vo nguyen giap dien bien phu bannedthought. Giap is considered one of the greatest military strategists of all time. The turning point foreign policy research institute. The goal of this paper is to give insight on orthodox, revisionist, and postrevisionist views. The idea that anti war protests and media coverage of the vietnam war eroded support and emboldened the north vietnamese army actually came from bui tin, a former colonel in the north vietnamese army. He later commanded the vietnam peoples army during the vietnam war. Minh, george boudarel, has published a book entitled giap.
Some very good accounts of the campaigns of 1914 had been written by 1916 and during world war ii one could follow the unfolding of the strategies of the major contestants with great ease by map, photo graph, article, and book. He commanded the peoples army that won a smashing victory against french imperialist troops in 1954 at dien bien phu, and guided the efforts of tens of millions of vietnamese that drove u. Revisionists do not believe the war was lost on the battlefield but was lost due to poor decisions and lack of attention to the war. Feb 22, 2021 how we won the war by general vo nguyen giap vietnam war book paperback. As far as we re concerned, theres no such thing as a purely military strategy. Details about how we won the war by general vo nguyen giap vietnam war book paperback. A near fine book in stapled wrappers with light wear to the front cover.
See the article in its original context from september 6, 2002, section a, page 23 buy reprints. Giap s strategy of revolutionary war totally integrated two principal forms of forcearmed force and political force, military dau tranh and political dau tranh. How we won the war by general vo nguyen giap vietnam war. Vo nguyen giap, born 1912, an xa, vietnamdied october 4, 20, hanoi, vietnamese military and political leader whose perfection of guerrilla as well as conventional strategy and tactics led to the viet minh victory over the french and to the end of french colonialism in southeast asia and later to the north vietnamese victory over south vietnam and the united states. Ngo dinh diem in philip cattons book, diems final failure. Tells the full story of the man who fought three of the world s great powers and won. After a year in southern china, the com munist leadership returned to vietnam and hid in remote jungle near the chinese border. Oct 03, 2019 vo nguyen giap august 25, 1911october 4, 20 was a vietnamese general who led the viet minh during the first indochina war.
Politician and strategist and the strategy of general giap since 1964, but their content is. Vietnamese communists must also possess a proper strategy to win the war. I told giap, and the second day he came back and said he could not abandon his ccmrades and act like an egoist. There might be more specific quotes about vvaw and kerry in giap s memoir how we won the war and a timelife documentary the ten thousand days war. Published on the first anniversary of the vietnamese victory over the most. If anyone lost it was the people of laos and cambodia who came under communist rule after the war. It is an allout effort that sacrifices all economic development at home and creates a drain on the north that cannot be indefinitely.
The vietnam war was a long, costly and divisive conflict that pitted the communist government of north vietnam against south vietnam and its principal ally, the united states. In a recent article, chinas role in the vietnam war, in jayne werner and david hunt eds. An essay written in april 1972 on general giap and the north vietnamese 1972 gamble for a telling victory. Kerrys picture among vvaw people has some place of honor in a vietnam museum, iirc. Jun 24, 1990 in short, we sought a decisive victory that would persuade america to renounce the war.
However the reader would like to have fuller information. Giap said that within 48 hours of its founding, my new army won two successive victories. But the battles true toll would prove to be the hubris it bred in u. Jul 22, 2008 the united states pulled out of the vietnam war. He has written the definitive biography of one of history s greatest generals. May contain markings such as bookplates, stamps, limited notes and highlighting, or a few light stains. Oct 04, 20 giap is sometimes said to have made this statement in how we won the war, sometimes in an unnamed 1985 memoir. In awesome shape found at an estate sale of a retired marine. Join us in war thunder for free using this link and get a premium tank or aircraft and three days of premium time as a bonus. The two commentaries in the front are both by unabashed communist sympathizers who dont even understand the book well enough to see it for what it is, a 25 page peptalk, and see it instead as a how to guide for.
Mar 02, 2019 after world war ii, france assumed that it would retake control of its colonial holdings in southeast asia vietnam, cambodia, and laos. According to frisby, giap understood that protracted warfare would cost many lives but that did not always translate into winning or losing the war. Our peoples war of resistance was an allout one waged by the whole nation. Why the north vietnamese will keep fighting rand corporation. Search the worlds most comprehensive index of fulltext books. Start reading military art of peoples war for free online and get access to an unlimited library of academic and nonfiction books on perlego. We are very pleased to publish the english translation of a series of articles by general vo nguyen giap, member of the political bureau of the central committee of the viet nam workers party, vicepremier and minister for national defence of the democratic republic of viet nam, commanderinchief of the viet nam peoples army. Despite longrunning rumors that general giap wrote in his memoirs that the u. Feb 22, 2021 how we won the war by giap, vo nguyen book. How we won the war implies a discussion of the entire conlfict, but this book only deals with the final 1975 offensive. The vietnam war was not lost in vietnam it was lost at home. How the battle of the ia drang valley changed the course.
Jan 20, 2011 but we were elated to notice your media was helping us. In the final analysis, giap won the war despite losing many battles, and as long as the army survived to fight another day, the idea of vietnam lived in the hearts of the people who would support. How we won the war giap, vo nguyen paperback publisher. Giap s genius resides in his firm grasp of strategy, specifically revolutionary war or peoples war, as giap prefers to call it.
Win small gains by communism, large gains by nationalism. Published on the first anniversary of the vietnamese victory over the most powerful nation on earth, this book is now in its eighth printing. It changed the entire way that the united states approached the war. The us forces in vietnam were extremely mobile and had tremendous fire support. How we won the war by general vo nguyen giap vietnam war book paperback. The united states and japan should prepare for war with china. In the final analysis, giap won the war despite losing many battles, and as long as the army survived to fight another day, the idea of vietnam lived in the hearts of the people who would support it, and that is the essence of revolutionary war. North vietnams prime minister, general vo nguyen giap, its defense minister. Celebrating 100th birthday of vietnams hero general giap. Politician and strategist and the strategy of general giap since 1964, but their content is similar and they leave many questions unanswered. Insurgency, counterinsurgency, and the marines in vietnam. Is it true that the us never lost a major ground war battle. Vietnams top military strategist tells the secrets of their victory in may 1975. In a 2003 interview, giap explained that he envisioned the armys role as a means for organizing the masses to carry out a military struggle that would lead to a political revolution.
It has been used as a text by professors at 30 colleges and universities. The southeast asian people had different ideas, however. Technically, we were not at war, we were advisors but the congressional approval to fight in vietnam was not given. As world war ii progressed the communists grew stronger and developed a military force of their own, which was placed. After frances defeat by the vietnamese in the first indochina war, the u. He first grew to prominence during world war ii, where he served as the military leader of the viet minh resistance against the japanese occupation of vietnam. Just say that giap wrote this in his book as if giap had written only one book. Buy a cheap copy of how we won the war book by vo nguyen giap. Apr, 2017 fifty years ago today, one of the vietnam war s most ferocious battles broke out in the ia drang valley. Giap was the deputy prime minister of vietnam from 1955 to 1991. How the battle of the ia drang valley changed the course of.
Giap prefaced the drive in late 1967 with a diversion, striking a string of american garrisons in the. Giap recommended the resistance war will win by truong chinh, so i guess i. At the time he wrote these reflections on the war with the u. They were causing more disruption in america than we could in the battlefields. Recently, another group of scholars have weighed in on this subject. General giap has published his memoirs and confirmed what most americans knew. Giap s opposition to that war resulted in him being replaced as defence minister in 1980 and two years later lost his seat in the politburo. So it would be wrong to speak of tet in purely military terms. Vo nguyen giap is perhaps the most important figure in the early history of communist. These scholars, postrevisionists, do not even admit defeatarguing that the united states won the war by late 1970. Politician and strategist,4 a biography of the north vietnamese military.
360 951 1259 309 1206 37 1223 171 365 96 590 630 384 1482 1042 380 1416 1406 822 1243